A Few Words About Breasts: I enjoyed this short story because it was extremely relatable. Almost every girl goes through what the author goes through so it was easy for me to imagine the situations she was talking about, and understand what point she was trying to make. However, at one point i found myself wondering why some of the detail she put in there was neccessary, i started to lose track of the story when she weighed it down with some details i felt weren't important too it. Otherwise, i enjoyed it but mostly i feel because i was able to identify with the author so well and because her use of humor and rhetorical questions kept me interested.
The Androgynous Male: I really enjoyed this story. Although i could not relate to it as much at first, i liked the way the author presented himself, and the details he gave promoted the story along with giving me insite into his thoughts to why he wrote this story. Also, i never really thought about how males try to conform themselves to roles. The fact that this author didn't makes me admire him and trust him more as an author. He really opened my eyes and convinced me of his arguement, by using details that are all around us and in his personal life, to support it. His closing sentence really makes you think, and want to change how the world is making gender roles.
MiniVan Motoring: I really also liked this story, the author builds his credibility quickly by talking about how many old cars he has owned and gone through. He also uses easy to understand language that seems to relate to our age group. He also uses facts and details from credible sources, other than himself to build his credibility and prove his point. I also like how he switches up topics, but still keeps the same general overview of coming back to his van, it keeps my attention and keeps me interested in each new experience he is writing about. The idea that he is able to do this while still tying is all back to the van is interesting. He also will sometimes hit you with a crazy fact that you werent expecting, such as hitting the deer. My only problem is that I wish he had finished the story a little bit more, and talked about what happened with the van in his conclusion.
Surviving the Mustard Lid Days: The first paragraph immediately draws you into the story and makes you want to keep reading it. I can also relate to what she says about memories, because that actually is what it is like, so it builds her credibility for me knowing i can relate. I liked how she used phrases like "killed us with kindness." Sometimes however i feel the author threw in facts unneeded for no reason. She builds her credibility again by tallking about how values are fused into her character. I liked how she talked about emotion and how it forced her to write, it was very detailed and interesting to read. That sentence was just really good. I didnt really like how it was almost like she wrote a concluding paragraph, and then kept going. Lastly, the two final paragraphs really really touched me as a reader, because it was almost like you could see in the words how much she loved her grandparents, and how much they effected her life and choices.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I really agree with what you are saying about "The androgynous male" and "A few words about breasts". The only difference I had was that I could relate more to the androgynous male, instead of a few words about breasts. Obviously it is because I am a male, but i agree that it is very interesting to hear about the story of the other sex because it opens your mind up to put yourself in their position, and to see how different and similar these roles really are. Even though I did not go through the stage of wanting bigger breasts, I really found that essay quite ammusing, and I laughed a couple of times. It was just hard for me to believe that girls actually felt that way. I think it might be the same way for girls reading "The androgynous male" because they have never really had that prospective on the life of a young boy growing up. I don't know if it was planned to have those essays together but I thought it was very interesting reading them back to back.
ReplyDeleteI had a very similar reaction to "A few words about breasts" because I felt as though she brought in so many aspects to her argument that I got a bit lost. I agree that her humor was definitely a driving factor into why I kept reading however I felt the ending was unsatisfying, as though she went through that whole experience for no reason. Because of that I found this piece a bit disappointing.
ReplyDeleteI had a very different reaction to Minivan Motoring. You said: "I also like how he switches up topics, but still keeps the same general overview of coming back to his van, it keeps my attention and keeps me interested in each new experience he is writing about." For me, the switching topics, especially when he went from personal story to facts about old cars, threw me off. It lost my attention actually because I don't really care much about the history of Americans and cars though I do understand the ethos that seciton built. To me, the personal anecdotes were much more interesting.
ReplyDeleteI totally agree with you. i really enjoyed "a few words about breasts" because of its relatability and the authors use of humor. i felt it was the most interesting one to read and easy to follow.
ReplyDeleteI really liked the pathos towards the end of Surviving the Mustard Lid Days. I was also moved by the last two paragraphs because I can relate to it, and it made me reflect on my grandparents.
ReplyDeleteIn the Androgynous Male, I trusted the author and admired him as well. It is interesting to realize that males, and not limited to males, conform to a male stereotype.
I think a sense of humor and details makes these pieces what they are!